
Heat pump vs furnace: quick comparison
| Gas furnace | Heat pump | Dual fuel (both) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| How it heats | Burns natural gas to heat air directly | Moves heat from outside air using electricity, even in cold weather | Heat pump for mild cold, furnace kicks in below a set temperature |
| Cools the home too | No, needs a separate AC unit | Yes, runs in reverse as an AC in summer | Yes, through the heat pump |
| Install cost | $3,000 – $7,000 (furnace alone) | $4,500 – $9,000 (full system) | $6,000 – $11,000 (both units) |
| Monthly running cost | Lower in extreme cold with cheap gas rates | Lower in mild winters, rises in very cold snaps | Lowest overall, switches to the cheaper source automatically |
| Typical lifespan | 15 – 20 years | 12 – 15 years | 12 – 20 years, mixed |
| Performance below 20°F | Strong, unaffected by outdoor temp | Efficiency drops, needs backup heat strips | Furnace takes over, no performance loss |
Ductwork and sizing considerations
- Switching from a furnace to a heat pump with electric backup heat strips can need a larger electrical circuit, sometimes a panel upgrade if the existing panel has no spare capacity.
- Existing ductwork sized for a gas furnace's higher air temperature may need adjustment for a heat pump's lower discharge temperature to keep rooms feeling warm.
- A dual fuel system typically reuses the same ductwork as a standard furnace and AC setup, since it is built around the same air handler and furnace cabinet.
- Rooms far from the air handler may feel cooler with a heat pump than they did with a furnace, since the overall air temperature leaving the vents is lower; a contractor can check duct sizing to balance this.
Tax credits and incentives to ask about
Federal tax credits have periodically covered a portion of the cost of high-efficiency heat pumps and furnaces; the amount and eligibility rules change, so confirm current federal credit status with a tax professional or the contractor before you budget around it. Ask PSO and ONG directly about any current rebate programs for high-efficiency equipment, since utility rebate programs change from year to year and are not guaranteed to be available when you install.
Want a real price for your home?
Get a quoteQuick checks: which one makes sense for your home
- Do you already have natural gas service from ONG to the house? If not, adding gas service is a major added cost that often favors a heat pump.
- Does your current system have a furnace and a separate AC unit that are both near the end of their life around the same time? That is often the moment to consider switching.
- Is your home all-electric already, with no gas line? A heat pump, possibly with electric backup heat strips, avoids adding gas service.
- Do you want one system that both heats and cools, to simplify maintenance and replace fewer parts over time? A heat pump does both jobs.
- Is your electricity rate from PSO notably higher than typical ONG gas rates in a cold month? That tips the math toward keeping or choosing gas heat for the coldest weeks.
Noise and comfort differences homeowners notice
Gas furnaces typically produce warmer air at the vents, often 120°F to 140°F, which feels noticeably hot compared to a heat pump's output of around 95°F to 105°F. Some homeowners describe heat pump air as "cooler" even though the thermostat reads the same temperature, simply because the air leaving the vent is closer to body temperature. Heat pumps also run longer at lower output rather than short, intense furnace cycles, which many homeowners find quieter and more even, though the outdoor unit does make an audible noise during its periodic defrost cycle in winter.
How a heat pump works
A heat pump looks like a standard outdoor AC condenser but works in both directions. In summer, it pulls heat from inside the house and dumps it outside, the same as a regular AC. In winter, it reverses and pulls heat from the outside air, even when it is cold, and moves that heat inside. As outdoor temperatures drop toward freezing and below, a heat pump's efficiency drops too, since there is less heat available to extract from colder air.
Most heat pumps have electric resistance backup heat strips built into the air handler that kick in when the heat pump alone cannot keep up, typically below 25°F to 35°F depending on the unit. Those backup strips cost more to run than the heat pump itself, since they work like a space heater.
Heat pump vs furnace: which is cheaper to run?
Running cost in the heat pump vs furnace question depends on your gas and electric rates. A heat pump moves heat instead of making it, so it delivers 2 to 3 units of heat for every unit of electricity in mild weather. A gas furnace at 95% efficiency turns 95% of the gas into heat. In the Tulsa heat pump vs furnace math, where most days stay above freezing, a heat pump often costs less to run. In a hard cold snap below about 25°F, gas heat is often cheaper, which is why many homes here settle the heat pump vs furnace choice with a dual fuel system.
Heat pump vs furnace lifespan, safety, and space
An electric furnace (resistance heat) is the costliest to run of the three. If your home has one, the heat pump vs furnace comparison usually favors switching to a heat pump.
| Factor | Heat pump | Gas furnace |
|---|---|---|
| Typical lifespan | 10 to 15 years (runs year-round) | 15 to 20 years (winter only) |
| Carbon monoxide risk | None | Yes; needs a CO detector and venting |
| Needs gas line | No | Yes |
| Also cools the home | Yes | No; needs a separate AC |
| Outdoor equipment | One outdoor unit | AC condenser outside, furnace inside |
Common myths about heat pumps in a cold climate
- Myth: a heat pump cannot heat a home below freezing. Reality: it can, but its output and efficiency drop, which is why backup heat strips or a dual fuel furnace exist.
- Myth: a heat pump costs the same to run no matter the temperature. Reality: running cost rises as it gets colder, unlike a gas furnace, which performs about the same at 40°F or 10°F.
- Myth: a dual fuel system is complicated to operate day to day. Reality: the switch between the heat pump and furnace is automatic once installed; homeowners set one thermostat the same way as any system.
- Myth: heat pumps are a poor fit for this climate. Reality: winters here spend most of their hours in the 30s and 40s, which is within a heat pump's efficient range; only the coldest nights need backup heat.
How a dual fuel system works
A dual fuel, or hybrid, system pairs a heat pump with a gas furnace in the same ductwork. The system runs on the heat pump during mild and moderately cold weather, which is cheaper per hour to run than gas in most months. When outdoor temperature drops below a set point, often around 30°F to 40°F, the system switches to the gas furnace instead of using electric backup strips, which is cheaper to run in deep cold than electric resistance heat.
This setup costs more upfront since you are buying two heat sources, but it usually produces the lowest total yearly heating and cooling cost for homes that already have gas service.
Step-by-step: deciding what to install
- Step 1: Check your current setup. If you have a furnace and AC that are both over 12 to 15 years old, you are likely replacing both soon anyway, which is the natural time to compare options.
- Step 2: Confirm whether gas service already reaches your home. Adding new gas service where none exists adds a meaningful cost that favors going all-electric with a heat pump.
- Step 3: Ask a contractor to run a load calculation (a Manual J calculation) for your home's size and insulation, not just the removed unit's capacity, since oversized or undersized systems run less efficiently either way.
- Step 4: Get quotes for all three options: furnace plus AC, heat pump alone, and dual fuel, so you can compare total installed cost side by side.
- Step 5: Ask each contractor for an estimated monthly operating cost comparison based on your actual PSO electric rate and ONG gas rate, not a generic estimate.
- Step 6: Factor in any utility rebates. PSO and ONG sometimes offer rebates for high-efficiency heat pumps or furnaces; ask your contractor to confirm current programs.
Safety and maintenance notes
A gas furnace needs an annual inspection of the heat exchanger for cracks, since a cracked exchanger can leak carbon monoxide into the home's air supply. Keep a working carbon monoxide detector near sleeping areas if you have any gas appliance.
A heat pump's outdoor unit needs clearance from snow, ice, and leaves to run efficiently; a buildup of ice on the outdoor coil in winter is normal to a point, since the unit defrosts itself periodically, but heavy, lasting ice buildup means a problem and needs a technician.
Never attempt to work on refrigerant lines, gas valves, or electrical connections on either system yourself; these require licensed technicians and, for gas work, inspection under Oklahoma Construction Industries Board licensing.
When to call a pro
Call an HVAC contractor for a full load calculation and installed quote before replacing either system, rather than buying based on the size of the unit you are removing. Also call a technician if a heat pump is stuck in defrost mode, is blowing cold air during heating mode for long stretches, or a furnace shows any of the no-heat symptoms covered in a furnace-specific guide.
Prevention and upkeep
- Schedule a fall tune-up for a furnace and a spring tune-up for a heat pump or AC to catch problems before the season's extremes.
- Replace filters every 1 to 3 months regardless of which system you have; both lose efficiency and risk damage from restricted airflow.
- Keep the outdoor unit clear of debris, leaves, and at least 2 feet of open space for airflow year-round.
- Have backup heat strip elements checked yearly if you have a heat pump, since they run rarely but need to work reliably during the coldest nights.
Why this choice matters more in this climate
Winters here swing from mild 50°F days to hard freezes in the teens, sometimes with an extreme event like the Feb 2021 cold wave that stayed below zero for days. That swing is exactly the condition dual fuel systems are built for: efficient heat pump operation most of the season, with a gas furnace ready for the coldest nights when a heat pump alone struggles. Summers above 95°F with high humidity also mean cooling performance matters as much as heating, which a heat pump's dual-purpose design covers in one system.
Warranty terms differ: furnace heat exchangers often carry 20 years or lifetime coverage, while heat pump compressors usually carry 10 years when registered with the manufacturer.
Next steps for Tulsa homeowners
- Ready to fix it? talk to a heat pump technician — a licensed local pro calls back with a price.
- See AC installation.
- See new AC unit cost.
- See our repair or replace AC guide.
Questions Tulsa homeowners ask
Is a heat pump cheaper to run than a furnace?
In mild and moderately cold weather, yes, a heat pump typically costs less per hour to run than gas. In very cold weather below 25°F to 35°F, backup electric heat strips can make a heat pump cost more than gas for those hours.
What is dual fuel heating?
Dual fuel pairs a heat pump with a gas furnace in one system. It runs on the heat pump in mild cold and switches to the furnace automatically in deep cold, aiming for the lowest cost in both conditions.
How long does a heat pump last compared to a furnace?
A heat pump typically lasts 12 to 15 years, somewhat less than a gas furnace's 15 to 20 years, partly because it runs year-round for both heating and cooling.
Can a heat pump heat a home when it is below freezing outside?
Yes, but its efficiency drops as it gets colder, and most systems rely on electric backup heat strips below a set outdoor temperature to keep up with demand.
Do I need a furnace at all if I get a heat pump?
No, a heat pump alone with electric backup heat strips can heat a home without a furnace, though a dual fuel setup with both is often cheaper to run in a climate with real cold snaps.
How much does it cost to switch from a furnace to a heat pump?
A full heat pump system with outdoor unit and indoor air handler typically runs $4,500 to $9,000 installed, depending on home size and any ductwork changes needed.
Will a heat pump replace my AC unit too?
Yes, a heat pump replaces both your heating and cooling equipment, since it runs in reverse as an AC during summer.